4 things I wish I’d known about Charlotte transit
If we understand how the system works, we can better find a way forward
You’re reading Transit Time, a weekly newsletter for Charlotte people who leave the house. Cars, buses, light rail, bikes, scooters … if you use it to get around the city, we write about it. Transit Time is produced in partnership among The Charlotte Ledger, WFAE and the UNC Charlotte Urban Institute.
Debates on local transit and transportation often contain misconceptions. Let’s clear a few of them up.
by Ely Portillo
Charlotte’s path forward on transit is murky. It’s unclear when or if we’ll have a vote on a new one-cent sales tax. No one knows how to revive the stalled Red Line commuter rail. And with driver shortages and service cuts, bus ridership is in free-fall.
As we talk about how to move ahead, it’s more important than ever to have a common baseline and understanding of transit in Charlotte — what its goals are, how we pay for it now, who rides it and where. Watching the debates around transit in our community, I’ve noticed a few recurring misconceptions that keep bubbling up.
All of this got me thinking about my tender days covering transportation as a young reporter at the Charlotte Observer (I wrote about transit, growth and development in Charlotte going back to the mid-2010s). There was a lot I didn’t know, much of which I had to learn via corrections or snarky Twitter replies to my work.
Here are four things I wish I’d known about transit in Charlotte before I started writing about it. Maybe you already know some of these. Maybe you’ll learn something new. At the very least, I hope I can save you from a snarky Twitter reply or two.
1. Fares just aren’t that important
When I started writing about transit and transportation, I assumed that fares — money you put into the farebox or use to purchase a ticket — paid for most of the system’s operating costs. But fares are a small piece of the revenue picture for the Charlotte Area Transit System. And with ridership still in a crater post-pandemic, fares have become even less important.
Most of CATS’ operating budget comes from the half-cent transit sales tax applied to purchases in Mecklenburg County. Even people who know that often don’t know quite how little fares contribute to CATS’ revenue.
In fiscal 2023, CATS’ total operating budget is $211 million. But CATS is projected to collect only $13.4 million in fares.
More than half of CATS’ operating budget comes from the sales tax (this year, CATS is expecting to receive $135 million). The rest comes from a mix of sources including federal funds, pandemic relief money and advertising revenue.
Understanding the insignificance of fares as a revenue source for CATS is key to understanding why proposals like making the transit system free aren’t that far-fetched. And it’s also key to understanding why CATS can’t simply raise fares to cover the cost of its planned multi-billion dollar expansion (and why the system doesn’t seem too worried that many fareboxes are broken).
2. Trains get the glory, buses get the job done
OK, that subhead is a slight exaggeration. But if you’ve lived in Charlotte for any length of time, you’ve seen the dramatic and much-celebrated opening of the Blue Line light rail and the Blue Line extension to UNC Charlotte. And in the $13.5 billion Charlotte Moves expansion plan, the single biggest, and costliest, item is the east-west Silver Line.
All of the focus on rail has obscured a simple fact in Charlotte, however: Buses have historically carried the lion’s share of passengers. In 2018, the last full pre-pandemic year, federal statistics show the Blue Line light rail carried 7.1 million passengers. Local buses carried 14.9 million.
“Without an adequate bus system you cannot have an adequate mass transit system,” said Mayor Vi Lyles in 2021.
So why the disproportionate focus on trains? To some degree, it likely reflects deep biases. There’s a longstanding stigma around riding the bus. Many people associate buses with riders who don’t have a choice and use transit as a last resort. On CATS, bus riders are more likely to be low-income (34%) and minority (68%) than light rail riders (15% and 49%, respectively), according to a 2017 CATS study.
As bus ridership continues falling, however, the historic imbalance in ridership might be reversing. In June, CATS local buses carried 380,972 passengers. The Blue Line carried 395,059 — which appears to be the first time the Blue Line ever carried more passengers in a month than local buses.
(For comparison, in March of 2020, right as the pandemic was starting, CATS local buses accounted for 709,277 passengers, while the Blue Line carried 471,880).
So, why don’t we just take all the money we’re thinking about spending on trains and buy the world’s biggest bus fleet? That leads to the next thing I wish I’d known.…
3. Transit is about economic development, not just moving people
While it might seem like transit is mostly about moving people from Point A to Point B, don’t underestimate the importance of building booms that accompany new transit projects. All you have to do is compare South End pre-Blue Line to South End now.
And trains signify a level of permanence that buses simply don’t. You can’t move the rails, after all. A new rail line is a highly visible signal that investment is coming. So, of course policymakers love trains. What other magic elixir can transform barren blocks of old industrial buildings into a gleaming second skyline in just a decade and a half?
City Council member Tariq Bokhari framed the issue succinctly at a planning retreat last year.
“Look back at that Blue Line. I think the impact that that has made on transit in the city compared to that of the impact it's made on economic development is a rounding error,” he said. “When you look at the number of people it moves a day versus the economic impact and the transformation it had on South End, it was an economic bet.”
Understanding the premium that local decision-makers place on the economic development impact that trains can have is key to understanding the local discussion around transit expansion. The hope of creating the next South End is driving decisions around where to route the Silver Line (such as CATS’ plan to push the line through the less-developed northern part of uptown instead of bringing it through Trade and Tryon streets).
Trains are also generally faster and more reliable than buses, since they don’t get caught in traffic. But if you think the transit expansion is only — or even primarily — about moving people and alleviating congestion, you’re missing a big part of the picture.
CATS bus drivers actually work for an independent, private company called Transit Management of Charlotte.
4. CATS bus drivers don’t work for CATS
OK, after all the chaos lately in the bus system, this last one is definitely more widely known than it used to be. But when I started covering transit, I had no idea that CATS bus drivers actually work for an independent, private company.
The reasons are complex, but they basically boil down to this: Before 1976, transit was private in Charlotte. When the city got into the business, acquiring buses and operating routes, federal rules required that unionized drivers maintain their union status. But North Carolina state rules forbid cities from negotiating with unions.
So, ever since, bus drivers have been employed by private companies hired to run the city-funded bus system. Bus drivers belong to the SMART Transportation Division Local 1715 union, and are technically employed by a company called Transit Management of Charlotte. A third-party management company — currently RATP Dev USA — operates that firm.
RATP Dev is responsible for overseeing, operating and maintaining the bus system, including supervising all of the bus operators and mechanics. The city renewed its contract with RATP Dev in 2019.
It’s not a secret, but it’s not exactly common knowledge that CATS pays a private company to run its buses. Even some City Council members were surprised to learn the extent of RATP Dev’s responsibility for running CATS’ bus system, a recent WBTV story found.
The workaround can lead to some convoluted situations. For example, City Council member Larken Egleston asked in July whether RATP Dev officials could come talk to them about the challenges facing the bus system and potential solutions.
“Given the role that RATP Dev plays in a lot of this and the control they exercise…would it be useful for us to have leadership from RATP Dev at our August committee meeting?” he asked.
But since RATP Dev is in the midst of negotiating a new contract with bus drivers and the SMART union, CATS chief executive John Lewis said that wasn’t a good idea.
“Once the collective bargaining process is complete, I think that would be an option,” said Lewis.
That effectively leaves City Council in the awkward position of trying to figure out how to fix its bus system without being able to talk to the actual company operating it.
There you have it: The four things I wish I’d known at the beginning, rather than figuring out along the way. No one knows where Charlotte’s transit system is headed. But if we can get on the same page and talk about it without having the same misconceptions, we might have a better chance of figuring out how to get there.
Ely Portillo is assistant director at the UNC Charlotte Urban Institute. He previously spent a decade as a reporter at The Charlotte Observer.
‘Offset’ option recommended for South End light rail stop: The Charlotte Area Transit System is recommending a new light rail station in South End that will have platforms that are not across from each other, known as an “offset” option. It will have a pedestrian track crossing between the two sides, and the stop will be between the New Bern and East/West stations, near the Publix and Sycamore Brewing. Officials hope it will be open by the end of 2026. Transit Time examined the options for the stop last month. (WSOC)
Questions about record of CATS manager: The private company that manages bus operations for the Charlotte Area Transit System hired a general manager for Charlotte in 2020 who had resigned from a previous transit job in Florida after being accused of providing improper inside information to a contractor. The executive, Ben Limmer, was hired by RATP Dev, the contractor that manages CATS’ bus service, as general manager of the bus operations division for CATS. CATS CEO John Lewis said CATS did not vet Limmer’s record with the Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority because Limmer was not a city employee. It’s unclear when Limmer left his position overseeing CATS service. (WBTV)
More money coming for roads: The N.C. Department of Transportation’s funding shortfall is being eased by the state legislature’s decision to use sales taxes instead of solely gas taxes to help pay for road projects. At a meeting of the State Board of Transportation last week, officials said that while there is still a shortfall, the addition of $628 million per year by 2025 will mean more projects will get built this decade. Local projects on the books with a date include widening I-85 in Gaston County to eight lanes, with construction slated for 2025. (N.C. Tribune)
Did somebody forward you this newsletter and you need to sign up? You can do that here:
Other affiliated Charlotte newsletters and podcasts that might interest you:
The Inside Politics newsletter, available from WFAE.