Transit Time: As Charlotte grows, is transportation funding keeping pace?
You’re reading Transit Time, a weekly newsletter for Charlotte people who leave the house. Cars, buses, light rail, bikes, scooters … if you use it to get around the city, we write about it. Transit Time is produced in partnership among The Charlotte Ledger, WFAE and the UNC Charlotte Urban Institute.
The city plans to ask voters to approve millions in bonds to build sidewalks and resurface streets. But the needs far outweigh the money; ‘just a drop in the ocean’
The city built a sidewalk on Barclay Downs Drive in south Charlotte last year. Although the city is proposing to triple the amount of money spent on sidewalks in this bond cycle, it won’t come close to funding the 245 miles of sidewalks that are needed.
by Ely Portillo
Charlotte is planning to ask voters this year to approve more than $100 million worth of new transportation bonds — an amount that would allow the city to make progress on goals like building more sidewalks but still fall short of covering many crucial needs.
Municipal bonds aren’t quite as sexy as a multibillion-dollar new light rail line or as captivating as a pitched political battle over a new sales tax, but they play a key role in the city’s growth. Voters typically approve bond packages every two years, allowing Charlotte to borrow money for major projects and ongoing programs such as subsidizing new affordable housing construction. (In 2020, Charlotte’s three bond referenda won with more than 77% of the vote.)
A draft proposal shows Charlotte is planning to ask voters to approve $198 million in general obligation bonds this year, about $118 million of which are for transportation projects. The city could choose to increase the total amount by up to $37 million, based on estimates of how much more Charlotte could afford to borrow.
City staff detailed their plans, and the size of the need, at a pair of meetings over the last week. The amount of available funding vs. the cost of needed projects reveals how far Charlotte still has to go in many areas.
Referring to a proposed sidewalk funding increase, City Council at-large member Dimple Ajmera put it bluntly: “This $50 million investment is just a drop in the ocean, similar to what we’re doing with affordable housing.”
Or, as council member Ed Driggs said: “The numbers are big. … We’re facing some tough choices here.”
Here’s a breakdown of the city’s planned 2022 bond spending on transportation in several key areas:
Sidewalk funding to triple, but gaps remain
Charlotte is planning to more than triple the amount it spends on sidewalks and pedestrian safety in the 2022 bond cycle, to $50 million. That’s up from $15 million in the last bond cycle. It’s reminiscent of the city’s affordable housing trust fund bonds, which Charlotte increased from $15 million to $50 million in 2018.
Charlotte Department of Transportation Director Liz Babson told council members that the city is running into higher costs on everything from real estate acquisition to labor and materials as it builds out its network of sidewalks. New projects are running between $4 million and $8 million per mile.
“We’ve been able to complete some of the lower-cost, less impact projects,” said Babson. “We’re continuing to see those increases in cost because we’re starting to construct some of the more complicated projects.”
“We’re coming into areas that are much more suburban. … A sidewalk project in those areas is starting to cost in the range of almost a street construction project,” she said.
Charlotte currently has 11 miles of sidewalk projects underway. The increased bond funding will allow the city to finish those and move forward with its next five miles of prioritized projects, as well as bring some of the seven miles of projects currently being evaluated closer to reality.
But there are still 245 miles of thoroughfares identified in Charlotte that don’t have sidewalks (some don’t have any, while some have sidewalks on only one side of the street). Most of those are in the city’s newer, more sprawling and suburban areas, along roads and neighborhoods built up in the 1970s, 1980s and early 1990s, before Charlotte’s sidewalk requirements went into effect. Relatively few are in Charlotte’s wealthier southeast “wedge.”
Plenty of major roads in Charlotte have no sidewalks (in red), according to the Charlotte Department of Transportation. The city built five miles of sidewalks in 2020.
“This is kind of the reason why it’s a tale of two cities,” said council member Renee Johnson. “We talk about bridging the wealth gap and looking at things from a racial equity perspective. I think this is an area where we could make a really big impact. …Areas are being left behind.”
Closing those gaps will be pricey: At the low end of the city’s cost estimate, building 245 miles of sidewalks would hypothetically cost almost $1 billion.
“We have a huge need, and our progress towards meeting that need is slow at this point,” said Driggs.
Although Charlotte has a goal of building 10 miles worth of new sidewalks a year, the city hasn’t kept up with that. In fiscal year 2020, Charlotte completed just under five miles of new sidewalks.
Charlotte’s bonds aren’t the only source of sidewalk funding. Developers also build sidewalks when they’re doing other projects, and the state builds some along roads it controls as well. The proposed $13.5 billion Charlotte Moves transit plan could also provide funding for sidewalks, if it moves forward (the plan relies on a 1-cent sales tax for Mecklenburg that currently has no clear path forward in the legislature).
Charlotte is also hoping to make it safer for people to cross the street. The city has installed 60 enhanced pedestrian crossings, with flashing beacons and other safety features. Another 35 are funded, and the additional sidewalk and pedestrian safety bond money will allow another 15 priority crossings.
There are an additional 47 identified locations that need enhanced pedestrian crossings in the city which aren’t funded
Eliminating traffic deaths — Vision Zero
Charlotte’s falling behind on its goal of ending traffic deaths by 2030 — in fact, it’s moving in the opposite direction. With traffic deaths rising, the city is looking to double its funding for the “Vision Zero” initiative — from $2 million to $4 million.
That money would go toward initiatives like neighborhood traffic calming projects, technology (think those automated signs that tell you when you’re driving too fast) and improved street lighting. The money won’t go that far, however: Adding street lights costs roughly between $200,000 and $300,000 per mile, and Charlotte has 141 miles of thoroughfares without street lighting.
Currently, the city has 19 miles of street lights funded. The upcoming bonds would allow for building roughly another 15 miles.
As with sidewalks, however, city bonds aren’t the only way to add street lights. Charlotte recently received a $1 million grant from the Charlotte Regional Transportation Planning Organization to install street lights on an eight-mile stretch of W.T. Harris Boulevard, from Mt. Holly Huntersville Road to I‐85.
Street resurfacing: more potholes coming?
It’s one of the most mundane municipal government functions: Fixing the potholes. But street resurfacing has actually become a big challenge in Charlotte, because the city’s street network is expanding while funding goes down.
“That’s an element we’ve struggled with over the years, the growth,” said CDOT official Charlie Jones. The city maintains about 5,424 lane-miles of streets (one mile of two-lane road = two lane-miles), though the state maintains many major thoroughfares like W.T. Harris Boulevard and Providence Road.
Each year, the city adds about 30 lane-miles to its road network. At the same time, because of cuts in state funding allocations, the amount Charlotte has available for resurfacing shrank from $26 million in 2020 to $19.2 million last year.
The 2022 bonds include $8 million for street resurfacing (the same as last bond cycle), but wouldn’t make up for the shortfall from the state. As a result, Charlotte’s street resurfacing cycle is about 35 years — even though the average lifespan of pavement is around 18 to 20 years.
As of now, about 62% of Charlotte streets are rated “good” or “very good,” Jones said. But if funding doesn’t keep up with rising needs, you could see a lot more potholes around Charlotte in the coming years.
Other projects: bike paths, bridges
The city’s proposed transportation bond package so far also includes:
$8 million for more bicycle infrastructure
$12.7 million for improvements at the Eastway/Shamrock Drive intersection
$5 million for bridge repair and replacement throughout the city
$10 million for various smaller “congestion mitigation” projects
Council member Greg Phipps said the big needs and limited resources show the need for prioritization.
“At some point, we have to be realistic and come to the realization that I don't know if we will be able to fund all of these projects in our lifetime,” he said, “or maybe in somebody else’s lifetime.”
Ely Portillo is assistant director at the UNC Charlotte Urban Institute. He previously spent a decade as a reporter at The Charlotte Observer.
In brief…
Red-light cameras rejected in Greenville: The state Court of Appeals ruled that the red-light camera program in Greenville, N.C., is unconstitutional because it doesn’t give enough money to the local school system. Under N.C. law, school districts must receive at least 90% of the total fees and fines collected. Two motorists who faced $100 fines sued the city. (Associated Press)
Bulletproof shield on buses? At a news conference this week, City Council member Tariq Bokhari and other Republicans running for city council said they had partnered with local manufacturers to create bullet-resistant barriers on CATS buses. The issue of driver safety has come to the forefront following last month’s shooting death of driver Ethan Rivera. CATS said it was unaware of the efforts to build a bulletproof shield and is open to discussing the “feasibility of the technology.” (Observer)
Electric bus manufacturing delayed: British electric vehicle maker Arrival has indefinitely paused plans to build electric buses in Rock Hill, which were previously scheduled to start in the second quarter. The company said it is shifting focus to building buses in the United Kingdom but still plans to build buses in Rock Hill at an undetermined future date. It still plans to produce electric vans in Charlotte starting in the fourth quarter of this year. (Charlotte Business Journal)
Car hit by light rail: Three people were injured Monday when a driver on Old Pineville Road drove a car around crossing arms and was struck by a Lynx train. The injuries were not believed to be life-threatening. (WBTV)
Transit Time is a production of The Charlotte Ledger, WFAE and the UNC Charlotte Urban Institute. You can adjust your newsletter preferences on the ‘My Account’ page.
Did somebody forward you this newsletter and you need to sign up? You can do that here:
Other affiliated Charlotte newsletters and podcasts that might interest you:
The Charlotte Ledger Business Newsletter, Ways of Life newsletter (obituaries) and Fútbol Friday (Charlotte FC), available from The Charlotte Ledger.
The Inside Politics newsletter, available from WFAE.
The UNC Charlotte Urban Institute newsletter and the Future Charlotte podcast from the Urban Institute.
 | A guest post by
|