Transit Time: Small N.C. towns replace buses with on-demand shuttles
You’re reading Transit Time, a weekly newsletter for Charlotte people who leave the house. Cars, buses, light rail, bikes, scooters … if you use it to get around the city, we write about it. Transit Time is produced in partnership among The Charlotte Ledger, WFAE and the UNC Charlotte Urban Institute.
Wilson, east of Raleigh, auctions off old buses as town-funded Uber-like service takes off; A ‘blessing’ for those without cars, but will it become too popular?
by Nick de la Canal, WFAE
It’s about 9 a.m. on a Tuesday, and an eighth-grader who only gave his first name, Caleb, is running late for first period.
A black minivan pulls up to his one-story, brick house, and he climbs into the backseat and collapses into the vinyl.
“I missed the bus this morning. Obviously, I overslept,” he said with a sheepish grin.
This isn’t the first time he's overslept, but this time, his mom can’t take him.
“Her car broke down, so she can’t really drive,” he said.
So with his mom's permission, Caleb ordered a ride from this van with his phone. It’s one of 15 shuttles in the city of Wilson that will pick residents up wherever they are and take them wherever they need to go.
This is the city’s public transportation system. The van’s driver, Samantha Lucas, takes a lot of kids to school each day, and a lot of people to work.
“It’s mostly workers ... and taking kids to school, and as it gets later, then you get the other folks that want to go to the shops and have a drink or whatever,” she said.
Lucas has been driving these on-demand shuttles ever since they replaced Wilson’s standard city buses in September 2020.
Not many people rode the bus back then. Lucas said they ran only once an hour, and the five routes weren’t that convenient.
“Like, if you go over on Airport (Drive), where I live, you couldn’t get on the bus, and it was limited,” she said. “With this system, you have more access to people all around the city of Wilson.”
Under the new system, riders order a shuttle through an app or by calling a number. They can catch a ride to anywhere within city limits for $1.50, with discounts bringing the cost down to $1 a ride, and they can pay with a credit card or a prepaid card from city hall.
Wilson’s city planner, Rodger Lentz, said the city first began exploring this idea in the 2000s.
“That’s when Uber and Lyft were becoming a thing, many years ago, and we were like, ‘Man, it would be kind of cool if transit was like that,’” he said.
At first, they tried to figure out how to do it themselves, but then the city partnered with New York-based Via, which provided software, vehicles and drivers in exchange for city funding. Lentz said it proved popular right from the start.
“In our first week, we had almost 600 trips, and then it doubled, literally, the next week. And then it went to like 1,500 trips the next week. So by the third or fourth week, we were already doing what the fixed-route had done before the pandemic, and of course, this was during the pandemic,” he said.
Now, about a year and a half later, Lentz said the shuttles are running about 3,500 trips a week, or more than double the 1,400 rides the old bus system ran in a typical, pre-pandemic week.
Lentz also said the shuttles aren’t just helping kids to school: They’re also getting people to work.
“Nearly 50% of trips are journeys to work, and we’ve asked questions like, ‘Has this system enabled you to get work?’ and we’ve got a lot of affirmative yeses,” he said.
Lentz said he thinks the system could be a game changer for rural towns like his, 50 miles east of Raleigh, where residents tend to have lower incomes and live farther apart, but still need access to food, jobs and community centers.
That includes Deanna Braswell, who climbed into a shuttle swinging a big mug of hazelnut coffee on her way to work at a local Food Lion.
She moved to Wilson three months prior without a car and said the shuttles have become her primary way to get around.
“It’s a blessing, really,” she said. “It’s my way of getting to work. It’s my way of, you know, paying my bills.”
Still, some critics have said this kind of public transportation will never be as efficient as buses, especially in higher-density cities and suburbs.
Jarrett Walker, who studies public transportation systems as a consultant for cities and towns around the world, said the taxi-like shuttles have potential downsides. While the shuttles may work in Wilson, he said, they could become a burden in other cities and towns if they get really popular.
“As soon as demand starts going up — or if you put out a service and it starts to become popular — you can’t carry very many people in each vehicle, so you have to start adding vehicles, and it becomes very expensive for the government to subsidize,” he said.
The city of Wilson — which has 48,000 residents — is paying more for the shuttles than it did for its old bus system. Lentz said the shuttles cost the city about $1.6 million a year, compared with $1.4 million the city spent on buses. However, he thinks the cost is worth it.
“For $1.6 million, we’re providing well over twice as many trips and covering 100% of the city with a system that picks you up within 15 to 20 minutes of your request, versus a bus that was only running once an hour.”
Lentz said the city held on to the old bus fleet just in case the new shuttles didn’t work out. But now, the city is planning to auction them off.
Other towns have begun looking to on-demand shuttles as public transportation too, including Salisbury and Elkin. Pilot programs have also begun in northeastern Wake County, Orange County, Mocksville Morrisville, and in Wilmington.
Nick de la Canal is a reporter for WFAE covering breaking news, arts and culture, and general assignment stories. Periodically, he tweets: @nickdelacanal . This article originally appeared on WFAE’s website and is republished with permission.
In brief…
Ambitious EV goal: Gov. Roy Cooper’s goal of having at least 1.25 million electric vehicles registered in the state remains a long way off. State data shows that North Carolina had 24,997 electric vehicles and 12,038 plug-in hybrids as of December 2021. (Axios Charlotte)
Speed hump requests: The city of Charlotte is considering new rules to make it easier for neighborhoods to request speed humps to slow traffic. Current rules require signatures from 60% of a neighborhood’s homeowners. (WFAE)
Streetcar up for award: The Charlotte Area Transit System’s CityLynx Gold Line Streetcar project is one of 12 finalists for a state award that honors “the state’s best projects that combine several modes of transportation.” Mecklenburg County’s Little Sugar Creek Greenway project is also a finalist. Awards are announced May 4. (N.C. Department of Transportation)
Transit Time is a production of The Charlotte Ledger, WFAE and the UNC Charlotte Urban Institute. You can adjust your newsletter preferences on the ‘My Account’ page.
Did somebody forward you this newsletter and you need to sign up? You can do that here:
Other affiliated Charlotte newsletters and podcasts that might interest you:
The Charlotte Ledger Business Newsletter, Ways of Life newsletter (obituaries) and Fútbol Friday (Charlotte FC), available from The Charlotte Ledger.
The Inside Politics newsletter, available from WFAE.
The UNC Charlotte Urban Institute newsletter and the Future Charlotte podcast from the Urban Institute.