Transit bill tightens requirements on road money
Bill expected to receive final approval today, head to governor; Referendum likely to be on November ballot
You’re reading Transit Time, a weekly newsletter for Charlotte people who leave the house. Cars, buses, light rail, bikes, scooters … if you use it to get around the city, we write about it. Transit Time is produced in partnership between The Charlotte Ledger and WFAE.
With the General Assembly expected to give final approval to the transit tax bill today, legislators move to prevent Charlotte from spending more on non-road projects
Charlotte officials had suggested that money from the proposed transit plan could free up money for other city priorities such as affordable housing, employee salaries and police. But state legislators have moved to restrict the city’s ability to increase spending on those projects.
by Steve Harrison
WFAE
Charlotte’s multi-year push to win approval in Raleigh for a transit tax referendum is expected to receive final approval from the General Assembly today.
But before it does, legislators have made a tweak to the bill to prevent Charlotte and other municipalities from replacing existing road money with new money from a proposed increase in Mecklenburg’s sales tax from 7.25% to 8.25%. Under the bill, which passed the Senate on Wednesday after passing the House last week, 40% of the money raised would go to roads and 60% would go to transit.
Last month, WFAE and Transit Time reported that Charlotte City Manager Marcus Jones said in a budget presentation that the new sales tax money for roads —more than $100 million a year — would relieve pressure on the city’s general fund budget.
Although Charlotte billed the transportation plan as a “roads-first” plan, Jones said money the city spends today on roads and sidewalks could be diverted to other purposes, like salaries for city employees. That money would then be backfilled with new money from the sales tax, he said.
“What’s important about the sales tax for transportation … is that (money) can go directly into our debt service bucket,” he said. “It gives us more capacity to take some of the property tax and put it back in the general fund budget, and that pays salaries for police officers, for firefighters.”
He added: “While it’s all about mobility, it provides some relief on the general fund and the property tax.”
The city later clarified that it had no intent to “zero-out” current spending on roads.
But the Senate transportation bill puts a stop to that discussion. Some legislators had read about Jones’ comments and objected to the idea that road money would allow additional spending in other areas. WFAE and Transit Time published an article about Jones’ comments on May 15, under the headline “Transit plan’s ‘road money’ would free up cash for other city priorities.”
“A lot of people who worked on this process were just as appalled when they read that,” said Sen. David Craven, R-Randolph, according to the N.C. Tribune.
The new provision calls for Charlotte and the six Mecklenburg towns to maintain road spending that’s at least equal to their average annual spending on roads for the last 10 years.
Some of the towns, too, had been considering using some of the money to increase spending on non-road uses. Cornelius’ town manager, for instance, said last year that freed-up money could be used for “parks, public safety, you name it.”
When the original half-cent sales tax for transit was approved by Mecklenburg voters in 1998, it required the city of Charlotte to continue spending a set amount of money on transit. The idea was to not replace the old transit spending with new transit spending.
The bill allows the city to discontinue making that “maintenance of effort” payment, which was about $28 million a year.
But the overall amount of spending on transit will increase dramatically. The bill would generate roughly $200 million for transit in the first year, in addition to the money already raised by the half cent transit tax.
Mecklenburg Commissioners are likely to vote this fall to place the tax referendum on the ballot for November.
Steve Harrison is a reporter with WFAE, Charlotte’s NPR news source. Reach him at sharrison@wfae.org.
Related Charlotte Ledger/Transit Time articles:
“Transit tax referendum appears likely” (June 25)
“The basics of Charlotte’s new transit plan” (August 2024)
Help us improve our coverage of transit as the referendum heads to the November ballot
From Tony Mecia of The Charlotte Ledger and Ely Portillo of WFAE:
Transit Time — which is a joint production of The Charlotte Ledger and WFAE — is committed to comprehensive and fair coverage of the upcoming transit tax referendum.
We’ve tracked this plan thoroughly since we launched this newsletter in May 2021. At the time, we wrote:
We’ll cover the city’s transit plan — honestly and fairly — which will be one of the top issues for Charlotte’s future as it’s debated in the next couple years.
Well, that “couple years” stretched into 4+ years, and as this plan enters a critical phase, we’ll be there, providing insights and analysis you can’t find anywhere else, with a variety of perspectives.
But to do it well, we need your help:
◼️ What would you like to see us cover?
◼️ What questions do you have that we can answer?
➡️ Let us know by dropping us an email at editor@cltledger.com.
—
Consider supporting our work
We’d also mention that while we make Transit Time free to all, it doesn’t just materialize. It costs money to produce.
If you’d like to support our efforts to provide thoughtful and balanced coverage of this important issue between now and November, consider these two options:
WFAE is in the middle of a pledge drive, at an important time for the future of public media. You can donate to WFAE here.
The Charlotte Ledger is a reader-supported publication. You can join as a paying member, if you haven’t already, or make a donation in support of our transit coverage.
Many thanks!
—Tony and Ely
Transit Time is a production of The Charlotte Ledger and WFAE. You can adjust your newsletter preferences on the ‘My Account’ page.
Did somebody forward you this newsletter and you need to sign up? You can do that here:
Other affiliated Charlotte newsletters and podcasts that might interest you:
The Charlotte Ledger, Ways of Life newsletter (obituaries), Real Estate Whispers (growth and development), Fútbol Friday (Charlotte FC) and Toppman on the Arts (arts reviews) available from The Charlotte Ledger.
The Inside Politics newsletter, available from WFAE.